Thinking about SUVs? The Ford Explorer usually pops up. Families really love it. Honestly, adventurers do too. But every single vehicle has its quirks. The Ford Explorer is no exception. Owners report all kinds of issues. It’s quite a mixed bag, I’ve seen.
Then, there’s the Ford Edge. Another very popular SUV, this one. It’s from the same company. Yet, the Edge shows a different reliability story. Let’s really dig into both. We’ll explore their upkeep troubles. We can check their reliability scores. What does this mean for a new buyer? It’s definitely worth thinking about.
Common Maintenance Issues of the Ford Explorer
The Ford Explorer has been around forever. It first came out in 1990, you know? It’s a true American vehicle icon. Over its many years, it faced problems. Owners frequently talk about these issues. The [National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)](https://www.nhtsa.gov/) tracks these things. They show common issues. Transmission troubles are one example. Electrical system failures also appear often. Excessive oil use is another big one.
To be honest, many owners of 2011-2017 models battled transmission issues. These models often used a 6-speed automatic transmission. Some drivers felt harsh shifting. Others even had full transmission failure. Imagine that happening far from home. It’s truly troubling to face such a breakdown. Repairing a transmission can cost a lot. It might be $1,800 to $3,500. The problem’s severity changes the price. [RepairPal](https://repairpal.com/reliability/ford/explorer) estimates an average annual maintenance cost. It’s around $733 for the Explorer. This is a bit higher than other SUVs.
Another issue keeps appearing. It’s tied to the electrical system. The 2016 model saw many reports. Its infotainment system often broke down. This could cause real safety worries. You’re driving, and the screen just goes blank. Electrical problems sometimes mean costly repairs. They usually average between $200 and $600. It’s a frustrating expense, that’s for sure.
Plus, many 2016-2019 Explorer owners noticed something. Their vehicles used too much oil. A study from the [Blue Oval Forum](https://www.blueovalforums.com/) examined this. About 35% of owners experienced it. This boosts maintenance costs. It also makes you fret about engine life. Will it really last? It definitely makes you wonder. Owners even share their stories online. Some had engine issues due to low oil. That’s a serious concern, I think.
Reliability Ratings Over Time
Looking at vehicle reliability means checking many sources. J.D. Power’s Vehicle Dependability Study is a big one. The Ford Explorer’s ratings have moved around. In 2021, it earned a 3 out of 5. That shows average reliability. But then in 2022, it dropped. It scored a worrying 2 out of 5. This fall matches reported issues. Especially the electrical and transmission ones. It seems like a clear pattern emerges.
The Ford Edge, on the other hand, has stayed steadier. J.D. Power gave it a 4 out of 5. That was in the same survey. This signals better reliability. Owners reported fewer issues overall. The Edge’s design is a bit newer. This might be part of the reason. It has fewer complaints about transmission issues. Electrical failures are also less common. Perhaps Ford truly learned some lessons. It’s interesting, isn’t it?
Comparative Analysis: Ford Explorer vs. Ford Edge
So, how do these two SUVs stack up? Both are good for families. They both offer spacious interiors. But their reliability truly sets them apart. Maintenance issues also differ a lot. It’s a tricky decision for many buyers. What do you truly value?
The Explorer often needs service more. This is true when we check repair frequency. [Consumer Reports](https://www.consumerreports.org/) did a survey. Around 20% of Explorer owners needed repairs. This was within the first three years. Only 15% of Edge owners reported this. That’s a noticeable difference. Come to think of it, those percentages tell a story.
The Explorer has a more complex drivetrain. Its infotainment system also uses advanced tech. These things can sometimes lead to more repairs. The Edge is simpler in some ways. It has been less prone to problems. Simpler can sometimes be better, I believe. It feels more robust.
That said, the Explorer offers more space. It has three-row seating. Its cargo area is also larger. For bigger families, it could be worth it. You might accept the potential risks. However, the Edge feels more reliable. This can be critical for daily drivers. Those who hate frequent repairs will likely love it. Frankly, reliability brings such peace of mind.
Historical Context of the Ford Explorer and Edge
Knowing their history helps us understand things now. The Ford Explorer arrived in the early 90s. SUVs were becoming very popular then. It met that rising demand perfectly. Over the years, it changed quite a bit. It went through several big redesigns. It adapted to what people wanted. But this fast evolution caused some growing pains. New technologies often brought new issues. I’m thinking particularly of those early rollover concerns, you know? The shift from body-on-frame to unibody for the Explorer was a huge step. This aimed to improve ride comfort and safety.
The Ford Edge came later, in 2006. It aimed to be a crossover vehicle. It offered sedan-like handling. It also had SUV comfort. Its design focused on a smoother ride. Better fuel efficiency was another goal. This attracted a different kind of buyer. The Edge truly benefited from Explorer lessons. It had fewer initial problems. They really took notes from past experiences, it seems. This approach paid off, offering a more stable start.
Future Trends and Predictions
The automotive world is changing fast. It’s all about electrification now. Enhanced technology is everywhere. Ford is investing heavily in EVs. They plan electric versions for both models. This transition might improve reliability. It could also reduce maintenance issues. I am excited to see what they come up with! Think about how quiet an electric SUV would be.
However, new tech often brings new challenges. Early electric vehicles can have different failures. Charging systems might act up. Battery management systems could pose issues. The success of these future models depends on Ford. They must address these concerns well. It’s a big test for them. Perhaps new problems will arise. But the potential for greater reliability is there.
Counterarguments and Criticisms
Many praise the Ford Explorer. Its spaciousness is a huge plus. Its versatility is also appealing. But critics often highlight its maintenance issues. Some say Ford hasn’t fixed these problems. This can make customers lose trust. Yet, loyal customers still love the Explorer. They swear by its capabilities. Especially for family trips, it’s a true workhorse for them. They look past the issues.
On the other hand, the Edge is known for reliability. Yet, some people feel it lacks something. They say it needs more robust features. Families on the go might want more. It seems like a trade-off exists. You choose between reliability and space. That’s a tough decision for many buyers. It makes you really think about your priorities. Are you a large family or a smaller one?
Actionable Tips for Potential Buyers
Thinking of buying an SUV? Here are some tips. They’ll help you pick between the Explorer and Edge.
Research common issues. Look for problems reported for your specific year. Websites like the [NHTSA](https://www.nhtsa.gov/) offer great insights.
Consider your actual needs. Big family or lots of gear? The Explorer might fit better. For city driving, the Edge could be smoother.
Always test drive both. Nothing beats real-world experience. Spend time in each vehicle. See which one feels right.
Look for certified pre-owned. If buying used, these are often better. They usually have extended warranties. They pass tough inspections.
Budget for maintenance. Every vehicle needs some care. Set aside money for it. Be ready for unexpected issues. It’s smart planning. Always.
Check vehicle history reports. A [Carfax](https://www.carfax.com/) report reveals past accidents. It shows service records too. This is really important.
Talk to current owners. Online forums are a goldmine. Get their firsthand experiences. They often share valuable advice.
Consider resale value. Some models hold value better. This affects your long-term cost. It’s worth a quick check.
Understand warranty coverage. New cars come with warranties. Used cars might too. Know what’s covered.
FAQs and Myths About the Ford Explorer and Edge
Q: Is the Ford Explorer a reliable vehicle?
A: It has had some reliability issues. Certain model years struggled. But many owners find it pretty dependable. Regular care is really important.
Q: Does the Ford Edge have fewer problems than the Explorer?
A: Yes, historical data suggests this. The Edge generally has fewer reported issues. Its reliability ratings are often higher.
Q: Are maintenance costs higher for the Explorer?
A: Yes, that’s generally true. The Explorer often costs more to maintain. Its systems can be more complex. It tends to need repairs more often.
Q: Can I expect long-term durability from either model?
A: Both can last many years. Proper care makes a difference. But the Edge shows more long-term reliability.
Q: How do their safety ratings compare?
A: Both vehicles often score well. The [IIHS](https://www.iihs.org/) and [NHTSA](https://www.nhtsa.gov/) provide ratings. It’s always smart to check specific year models.
Q: What are the best model years to buy for the Explorer?
A: Later models, post-2019, generally show improvement. They seem to have fewer reported issues. Doing your homework is key.
Q: And the Edge? Are some years better?
A: The Edge has been more consistent. But newer models often bring improvements. They benefit from refined designs.
Q: Do these SUVs hold their value?
A: Both tend to hold value fairly well. SUVs are popular, you know? The Edge’s reliability might give it a slight edge.
Q: What about engine options and their reliability?
A: The Explorer has offered different engines. Some EcoBoost engines had oil consumption worries. The Edge’s engines are generally solid.
Q: Is it true the Explorer is better for off-roading?
A: The Explorer often has more ground clearance. It’s designed for more rugged use. The Edge is better for city driving.
Q: What is the towing capacity like?
A: The Explorer typically offers higher towing capacity. It’s a bigger vehicle after all. It handles heavier loads better.
Q: Are hybrid options reliable for these models?
A: Hybrid tech is still evolving. Early adopters sometimes face new quirks. Ford is committed to making them reliable. I am eager to see how these perform over time.
Q: What’s a common myth about Ford SUVs?
A: Many think all Ford SUVs are prone to rust. Modern Fords have better rust protection. This is thanks to newer manufacturing.
Q: Is buying a used Edge always safer than a used Explorer?
A: Not always. A well-maintained Explorer can be great. A neglected Edge can still cause issues. It really depends on the car’s history.
Q: Do Ford Pass connectivity issues plague both?
A: Earlier versions of infotainment systems had glitches. Ford has worked to improve this. Software updates usually help a lot.
Q: Are parts expensive for these Fords?
A: Parts are generally available. Ford is a big brand. Costs can vary, of course. This depends on the specific repair.
Q: How often do I need service appointments?
A: Stick to the factory schedule. Regular oil changes are a must. Check your owner’s manual. It outlines everything you need.
Q: Can I save money by doing DIY maintenance?
A: For simple things, sure. Oil changes are manageable. But major repairs need a professional. Don’t risk bigger damage.
Q: What about depreciation? How fast do they lose value?
A: Like all new cars, they drop. SUVs tend to do better. Demand keeps them desirable. Reliability helps too.
Q: Is Ford customer service good for these issues?
A: Experiences vary widely. Some owners report great help. Others feel frustrated. Persistence often pays off.
Conclusion
To wrap things up, the Ford Explorer and Ford Edge are distinct. They serve different needs in the SUV market. The Explorer gives you space and versatility. But it has a reputation for maintenance issues. The Edge, however, boasts better reliability. It has fewer reported problems. It’s a solid choice for many drivers.
As consumers, we must weigh things carefully. Think about your personal needs. Consider your budget. Look at your lifestyle. The Explorer might be perfect for roominess. Perhaps it’s just what your big family needs. The Edge could be the fit for you. It offers reliability and peace of mind. Honestly, that means a lot for daily commutes.
Ultimately, cars keep evolving. Both these vehicles will adapt. We’re stepping into an electric future. It’s an exciting time for SUV fans. Whether you pick the strong Explorer or the dependable Edge, I am happy to see how both vehicles keep shaping the market and meeting drivers’ needs everywhere. Imagine a world where all vehicles are perfectly reliable. That’s a goal worth aiming for.
